
Visual
Wow... I must say WOW! it feels so much like the comics. The color palette, the cinematography, the set dressing, the camera placement... it is so well done. Such painstaking time went into adding all the visual layers to this story. (I can't wait to see the Blu ray behind the scenes on this). The movie is stunning. The only draw back for some I have heard is some of the costume designs on the hero versions of the characters like Spectra II and Owlman. I had no issue with the change but others did. It is different from the comics but similar in design if not execution. When placing a super hero costume on a real body sometimes you have to change it to make it look good instead of dorky. So I approve of the change.
Acting.
Normally I would do an actor by actor break down in this part of the review but everyone did so well It would be kind of strange having 8 paragraphs of nothing but praise. So I will say this. This ensemble was well put together, well directed and successful in their effort. Some didn't like Billy Crudup as Dr. Manhattan. He was a little too emotional for them. I thought he kept all his emotion buried where he didn't realize he had bottled them. I enjoyed his interpretation. I must mention the wonders of Jackie Earle Haley because his turn at Rorshack is so awesome. He really pulled this film together. He was really the most impressive here. He was Rorshack down to his freckles.
Soundtrack
I had one complaint. The soundtrack is inconsistent. Some songs just didn't belong in this film and jarred my emotional experiences taking me out of the spell of the story. For the most part I love the songs they picked for the soundtrack and the score is pretty good on the whole its just that 2 or 3 scenes could have been better served with different music.
Concerns
Okay I have 2 complaints. The climactic sex scene was a little long. Its stopped the pace of the movie with a visible lag. 2 minutes shorter and I think we would have no lag. Some complaints I have heard was for Dr. Manhattans lack of clothing. Well he ran around naked in the books... them movie is rated R so why not remain true to the story and leave him nude. Americans are a bit to sensitive of the nude body. I had no issue with it.
Bottom line
THE best comic book movie this year. (sorry wolvie) I can't say it is the best action movie as Star Trek is my pic for that this year. But its is second in line. I think any comic book fan of a mature age (over 17) should take a look at it. It is violent and titillating but thought provoking which is why I like it. It pushes your view of reality to expand your consciousness. Not everyone is going to like it. And that is okay. PANDY APPROVED.







